International logo contest/Ballot
| ←historical pages | 2003 Wikipedia international logo contest (ballot) | |||
This was an international contest held from July 20 to August 27 2003, gathering 150 proposals. After the early proposal by Chuck Smith on October 12, 2002, the contest was first proposed on June 14, 2003 by Erik Moeller, who argued that the logo (adopted in January 2002 from the Logo suggestions) was unaesthetic, not international, and portrayed a text-only Wikipedia.
| ||||
Other languages:
Deutsch: Internationale Logo-Wahl/Stimmzettel |
Esperanto: Internacia Logobaloto/Balotilo |
Français: Vote pour un logo international/Bulletin de vote
VOTING IS NOW CLOSED!
The voting period lasted from September 15, 20:00 UTC until September 25, 20:00 UTC.
Welcome to the final vote on our new logo. Please check out the list of finalists and then add your votes below. The two pages are kept separate to prevent logo swapping and the like.
We are using average voting for this vote. This means that you can grade each logo from 1 (very bad) to 5 (very good), and the logo with the highest average score wins. You have to vote on variants, not on a set of logos. The only exception is "logo 0", which is the option to keep the current logos.
You need a userpage on Meta for your vote to count. Please make sure that your user page points to an existing account on one of the Wikipedia projects with at least 10 contributions. Votes signed with "red" (non-existent) user pages or those pointing to users with no contributions will not be counted. See International logo contest/Vote instructions for details.
Please use the vote template at the bottom of this page as a start. A typical ballot would look like this:
- 1a: 4
- 2b: 4
- 5a: 3
- 6c: 3
- 0: 5 (they're so petty)
This means that this user (Exampleuser) has voted on logo variants 1a, 2b, 5a, 6c and 0 (old logo), with the votes being 4, 4, 3, 3, and 5. Remember: 5=good, 1=bad. It's OK to add short comments next to your vote, as shown above.
You are encouraged to vote on all variants! The more votes we get, the better the result. Please separate each vote with a horizontal line.
Note: this page is already over 30 kilobytes long. If your browser cannot edit pages over 30 kb, please use section editing to add your vote. Someone else will place it back at the right position.
Results
editThe results are generated from a script called vote.rb. The results include votes from non-English ballots and are listed on International logo contest/Results.
- 1a: 2 (too cluttered)
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 5 (the best)
- 6b: 4
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 1 (ugly, non-transparent)
- 7c: 2 (double brackets are ugly here; ant too large, text not centered)
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 4 (creepy ant bonus)
- 8: 3
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 3
- 11: 4
- 0: 1
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 5 (darn gray circle :-))
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 5 (now that's just cool.)
- 5a: 5
- 5b: 3 (kinda seems empty w/o the text)
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 3 (ditto)
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 4
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 4
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 5
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 3
- 11: 3
- 0: 1
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 3
- 2e: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 3
- 10: 4
- 11: 4
- 0: 5
Maveric149 20:33, 15 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 5 (captures the spirit of Wikipedia; unfinished puzzle, sphere=global, multilanguage.)
- 1b: 1 (the ant totally ruins this logo; it is also a thinly veiled effort to make the ant the default mascot)
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5 (maybe better as a Wikimedia logo... but it still rocks!)
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 3 (what happened to the language specific variant? I liked that one.)
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1 (looks very childish; ant must die since the Wikipede has more votes)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
Sansculotte 20:44, 15 Sep 2003 (UTC):
edit- 1a: 2 better keep the old logo
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 5
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 5
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 5 the best!
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 4
- 11: 4
- 0: 1 brrr
- 1a 1
- 1b 1
- 2a 1
- 2b 4
- 2c 4
- 2d 3
- 2e 2
- 3a 1
- 3b 3
- 4a 1
- 4b 4
- 4c 4
- 4d 3
- 5a 1
- 5b 1
- 5c 1
- 5d 1
- 5e 1
- 6a 1
- 6b 1
- 6c 1
- 7a 2
- 7b 4
- 7c 2
- 7d 2
- 7e 3
- 8 3
- 9a 1
- 9b 1
- 9c 1
- 9d 1
- 9e 1
- 10 3
- 11 1
Alex Anlicker 21:14, 15 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4
- 11: 1
- 0: 5
- 1a 1
- 1b 1
- 2a 2 (first two are alright, but this one reminds me of an info booth sign)
- 2b 2 (Y shape reminds me of YMCA)
- 2c 1
- 2d 1
- 2e 1
- 3a 1 (I didn't know that was a lamp!)
- 3b 2 (This one is decent)
- 4a 3
- 4b 3 (I don't like those sharp pointy things)
- 4c 4 (Good, I like the W nested in the dots...)
- 4d 5 (BY FAR THE BEST!!! Jurgen rules)
- 5a 1 (These look way too much like an M$ Windows advert)
- 5b 1
- 5c 1
- 5d 1
- 5e 1
- 6a 4 (very nice)
- 6b 1
- 6c 1
- 7a 1 (I'm not a big fan of the ant)
- 7b 3 (this is nice, simple little ant)
- 7c 1
- 7d 1
- 7e 1
- 8 3 (This concept has been used before, but it is still nice)
- 9a 1
- 9b 1
- 9c 1
- 9d 1
- 9e 1
- 10 4 (simple, not bad)
- 11 1
- 0 1
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 2
- 2d: 3
- 3a: 1
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 4
- 6a: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 2
- 1a: 5 (a good representation of wikipedia)
- 1b: 1 (ants are scary)
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 3 (reminds me too much of golf)
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 5
- 4c: 3 (too much like a colour blindness test)
- 4d: 5 (the best!)
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 1 (ants are scary)
- 7b: 1 (ants are scary)
- 7c: 1 (ants are scary)
- 7d: 1 (ants are scary)
- 7e: 1 (ants are scary)
- 8: 1 (looks deformed)
- 9a: 1 (ants are scary)
- 9b: 1 (ants are scary)
- 9c: 1 (ants are scary)
- 9d: 1 (ants are scary)
- 9e: 1 (ants are scary)
- 10: 5
- 11: 2
- 0: 3
I am Jack's username 2003-09-15t22:17z
edit- 1a: 5
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 3
- 8: 3
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 3
- 11: 2
- 0: 1
Jwrosenzweig 22:20, 15 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 5 (best of the proposed)
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 5 (I really prefer the logo we have now--but far be it from me to resist the wheels of change :)
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 5
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
Robert Merkel 23:11, 15 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:3
- 1b:1
- 2a:3
- 2b:4
- 2c:4
- 2d:5
- 2e:5
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:2
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:3
- 6b:2
- 6b:2
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:2
- 0:1
- 1a:1 (This is a good illustration. A logo MUST be simple though.)
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:4
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:4 (Interesting.)
- 5a:2
- 5b:3
- 5c:1
- 5d:3
- 5e:5 (Second best! Attractive, simple and reproducible.)
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1 (Not a logo. The designer has potential.)
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:5 (The best! Warm and sensitive. Very attractive and livens ones spirit.)
- 11:4 (Attractive, simple and reproducible.)
- 0:1 (Fear of change will hold us back)
Jdforrester 00:52, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 0:4
- 1a:2
- 1b:1
- 2a:5
- 2b:4
- 2c:3
- 2d:4
- 2e:5
- 3a:5
- 3b:3
- 4a:3
- 4b:3
- 4c:4
- 4d:4
- 5a:1
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:3
- 6a:2
- 6b:1
- 6b:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:3
- 7c:2
- 7d:1
- 7e:2
- 8:3
- 9a:2
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:2
- 10:2
- 11:3
- 1a:4
- 1b:5(the best)
- 2a:2
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:3
- 3a:1
- 3b:2
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:2
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:1
- 5e:2
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:3
- 9a:3
- 9b:1
- 9c:2
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:3
- 11:1
- 0:3
NuclearWinner 01:18, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 0:3
- 1a:3
- 1b:2
- 2a:3
- 2b:3
- 2c:4
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:4
- 4a:3
- 4b:3
- 4c:4
- 4d:5
- 5a:5
- 5b:4
- 5c:5
- 5d:4
- 5e:3
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:2
- 8:3
- 9a:2
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:4
- 11:3
- 1a:4
- 1b:5
- 2a:5
- 2b:2
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:2
- 3a:3
- 3b:4
- 4a:1
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:3
- 5a:2
- 5b:3
- 5c:2
- 5d:3
- 5e:4
- 6a:1
- 6b:2
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:2
- 7e:1
- 8:5
- 9a:1
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:3
- 10:3
- 11:2
- 0:2
- 1a: 5 (Very nice.)
- 1b: 1 (Bad combination. Ant gets lost)
- 2a: 1 (Not bad, but too generic)
- 2b: 5 (Very nice, my favorite.)
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5 (Good, but I'd like it better without the break, ala b)
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 3 (Nice, but too familiar.)
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 2 (I like blue.)
- 5d: 3 (Think that right-side gap could be closed)
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 4 (Like I said, I like blue.)
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a. 1 (too big, to detailed)
- 1b. 1 (even more detailed)
- 2a. 4
- 2b. 4 (might be a good wikiatlas logo)
- 2c. 3
- 2d. 2
- 2e. 1
- 3a. 4
- 3b. 5
- 4a. 4
- 4b. 3
- 4c. 4
- 4d. 5
- 5a. 5
- 5b. 4
- 5c. 5
- 5d. 4
- 5e. 1
- 6a. 1
- 6b. 1
- 6c. 1
- 7a. 1
- 7b. 1
- 7c. 1
- 7d. 1
- 7e. 1
- 8. 5
- 9a. 1
- 9b. 1
- 9c. 1
- 9d. 1
- 9e. 1
- 10. 5
- 11. 1 (too big)
62.39.210.15 04:45, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 3
- 1b: 4
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 5
- 7d: 4
- 7e: 4
- 8: 3
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 4
- 9c: 5
- 9d: 5
- 9e: 5
- 10: 2
- 11: 2
- 0: 5
- 1a: 5
- 2a: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 2
- 6a: 4
- 7c: 4
- 8: 3
- 9e: 5
- 9a: 5
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
Schneelocke 05:13, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 3.5
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2.5
- 2c: 2.5
- 2d: 2.5
- 2e: 2.5
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2.5
- 4a: 3.5
- 4b: 3.5
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 3.5
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 3.5
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3.5
- 6c: 2.5
- 7a: 3.5
- 7b: 3.5
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 3.5
- 7e: 4
- 8: 3.5
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 3.5
- 9c: 3.5
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 4
- 11: 3
- 0: 3 overall (some are ok, some, like the french logo and the old Nupedia logo, quite frankly really suck).
Stevertigo 05:16, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:5 (The current version sucks, but the concept rocks too much to simply nitpick details.)
- 1b:1
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4 (needs to wrap around the circle -- curves not flat faces)
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 4 (I like the split colors-- maybe one side blue, other orange)
- 3a: 2 (nah)
- 3b: 4 (sharp, with some plusses -- whats with the pen-- do we even use them?)
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 5
- 4c: 2 (severe deduction for using the W)
- 4d: 5 (Alright, the 3D warp is a very nice touch.)
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 4 (leaves in back---but why green? eugh)
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1 ( I like the ant-- I dont like it as a logo)
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1 (poorly done,too cartoonish-- so many variants as to be imposing)
- 10: 2 (very nice)
- 11: 1 (very nice)
- 0: 1 (needs work)
- 2b: 3
- 2e: 3 (nice)
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 4
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 3 (don't like the font)
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 5
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
Magnus Manske 07:23, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:5
- 5a:3
- 5c:3
- 10:4
- 0:2
- Re-formatted: Menchi 01:46, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 5
- 5b: 5
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 5
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 4
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 3
- 10: 5
- 11: 3
- 0: 2
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 5
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 5
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 2
- 0: 1
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 4
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 4
- 7e: 5
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 5
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 5
- 5b: 5
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 5
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 5
- 6c: 5
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 4
- 1a: 3
- 2c: 4
- 3b: 5
- 4a: 4
- 5a: 2
- 6a: 3
- 7a: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 2
- 0: 2
Pontauxchats 09:30, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 3
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 5
- 9b: 5
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 5
- 11: 2
- 0: 3
- 1a: 1 (too cluttered)
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 2 (love the smplicity of the 2x series)
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 3 (love the "embracing")
- 2d: 4 (looks good!)
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 2 (colours look weird)
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1 (don't like that ant!)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 3
- 0: 4
Andre Engels 10:11, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 4
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 5
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 4
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 3
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 4
- 0: 5
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 5
- 7d: 5
- 7e: 3
- 8: 4
- 9a: 5
- 9b: 5
- 9c: 5
- 9d: 5
- 9e: 5
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 4
Zenogantner 10:48, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 5
- 1b: 4
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 4
- 7e: 3
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 2
- 0: 3
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 4
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 4
- 7e: 4
- 8: 4
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 5
- 9c: 4
- 9d: 4
- 9e:5
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 3
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 5 (Emphasizes international and multilanguage)
- 1b: 1 (Miwiki superfluous)
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1 (Looks like a coat of arms)
- 3b: 2 (ditto)
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 4
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 1 (Book idea good, but I prefer bees)
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 1 (???)
- 9a: 1 (Prefer bees)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4
- 11: 2
- 0: 3
Stefan Kühn 21:12, 24 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 3a: 5
- 3b: 4
- 10: 4
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 1 (too noisy, popular so I'm beating it down)
- 1b: 1 (even noiser)
- 2a: 2 (power button)
- 2b: 2 (early 90s sports centre)
- 2c: 2 (late 90s sports centre)
- 2d: 2 (ditto)
- 2e: 2 (ditto)
- 3a: 3 (looks like it was cut out from a school pupil's blazer)
- 3b: 4 (ditto, but nicer)
- 4a: 3 (nice, but too simplistic)
- 4b: 3 (snowflake)
- 4c: 4 (nice)
- 4d: 5 (very nice - moving, but working together)
- 5a: 3 (looks like a recyled paper manafacturer)
- 5b: 2 (looks like a recyled paper manafacturer without a name)
- 5c: 4 (nicer than the green)
- 5d: 2 (no name)
- 5e: 3 (a tad crowded)
- 6a: 2 (a bit too styled)
- 6b: 2 (green never looks good on websites (/.))
- 6c: 2 (noisy)
- 7a: 5 (clear)
- 7b: 3 (squashed)
- 7c: 3 (ant looks ill when blue)
- 7d: 5 (clear)
- 7e: 4 (squashed)
- 8: 1 (too corporate, dated)
- 9a: 5 (nice, clear)
- 9b: 4 (not as nice)
- 9c: 5 (better than 9a)
- 9d: 3 (crowded)
- 9e: 2 (looks broken)
- 10: 5 (boring, but I like it more than 1)
- 11: 1 (makes us look like a christian organisation)
- 0: 1 (no colour, just a smudge)
Ryan_Cable 15:45, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 5
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 5
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 1 (it seems Watermanntm)
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1 (we can't note with 0 but i do *not* like the 4's serie)
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1 (and why not Nutella)
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 3 (it would be better if transparent)
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 4
- 7e: 5
- 8 : 1
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 2
- 11: 2
- 0 : 2
- 1a: 5 (I hope there will be a non-colour version too)
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 5 (I really like the old one)
- 1a: 1 too cluttered
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4 - I like it but it looks too much like power switches and other logos
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 5 -
- 2d: 4 - not as nice with the outer circle cut
- 2e: 2 - left and right in different colours is off-putting
- 3a: 4 - nice but makes me think of an electricity company
- 3b: 2 - with the circle in grey it appears to decompose into too simple shapes -- makes it dull
- 4a: 3 - fairly nice stylised W
- 4b: 2 - it's just a snowflake. a bit dull
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 4 - funky!
- 5a: 2 - nice graphic, but not square (bad for page design) and includes the text (ditto)
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 3 - better.
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10: 3
- 11: 2
- 0: 1 - non-uniform, and country flags should not be on Wikipedia
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 4
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 4
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 2
- 10: 2
- 11: 3
Nommonomanac 18:50, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 2 (too much)
- 1b: 1 (just scary)
- 2a: 1 (information centre)
- 2b: 1 (leisure centre)
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1 (looks like old Woolworths logo)
- 3b: 1 (very 70s colour-scheme)
- 4a: 4 ('90s science text-book)
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 2 (too dotty)
- 4d: 2 (software house)
- 5a: 3 (textbooks for sale)
- 5b: 3 (not sure about the hole though)
- 5c: 3 (same colour as a chemical toilet)
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 1 (garden centre)
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1 (not mad on the ants)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3 (bit too normal)
- 9a: 2 (what happened to the wikipede?)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4 (good use of brackets)
- 11: 1 (anything but this)
- 0: 2 (rather dull)
- 1a: 5 (my personal favourite)
- 1b: 1 (the ant ruins it)
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 2 (I'm using a keyboard, not a pen)
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 1 (reminds me more of a snowflake)
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 1 (open right side bothers me)
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1 (same here)
- 5e: 1 (the text looks like it's just been slapped on the books)
- 6a: 1 (the text looks horrible)
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1 (there you have those ants again - brrr!)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1 (these insects are really hard to get rid of!)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 2 (but it was nice while we had it...)
Sebastian Wallroth 19:44, 16 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 3
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 4
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 5
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 5
- 0: 2
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 1 (sorry olie, I prefer without ant )
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 4 (simple but beautiful)
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 4.5 (Anything 4.5 and above I consider worth of being a wikipedia logo)
- 1b: 3.0
- 2a: 3.0
- 2b: 3.5
- 2c: 5.0
- 2d: 4.0
- 2e: 4.5
- 3a: 4.0
- 3b: 4.5
- 4a: 1.5
- 4b: 1.5
- 4c: 1.5
- 4d: 1.5
- 5a: 3.0
- 5b: 3.0
- 5c: 3.5
- 5d: 3.5
- 5e: 3.0
- 6a: 4.0
- 6b: 3.5
- 6c: 3.0
- 7a: 3.0
- 7b: 2.0
- 7c: 1.0
- 7d: 1.0
- 7e: 1.0
- 8: 2.0
- 9a: 2.0
- 9b: 2.0
- 9c: 2.0
- 9d: 2.0
- 9e: 2.0
- 10: 1.0
- 11: 4.5
- 0: 3.0
- 1a: 2 (I don't mind the concept, but it's rather cluttered)
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 3 (good and clean, but not very encyclopaedia-y)
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 2 (the extra colour confuses it compared to 2b)
- 3a: 1 (like a 70s colour television manufacturer)
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1 (not interlingual enough, because there's no W in, for example, the Esperanto Vikipedio)
- 4b: 1 (biotech)
- 4c: 1 (see 4a)
- 4d: 1 (fine for a mobile phone company)
- 5a: 2 (this isn't bad, but isn't it the wrong shape for use on the website?)
- 5b: 3 (better shape)
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 5
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 3 (rather similar to Britannica's logo, no?)
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1 (I'm not keen on this ant thing)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 2 (prefer the look of this ant)
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1 (Stop it! It's eating the Wikipedia!)
- 10: 3 (nice brackets, but it would be better if they enclosed a simpler shape)
- 11: 2
- 0: 2 (it's better to have something internationally consistent)
- 1a: 3 (I really like the concept and the look, but it's just too "busy" and I worry that it doesn't scale well, work on paper in black in white, work on low res' and low colour depth screens...)
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 5 (I really like the simplicity - it does everything the puzzle-globe one doesn't)
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 0
- 7b: 0
- 7c: 0
- 7d: 0
- 7e: 0
- 8: 0
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 0
- 9c: 0
- 9d: 0
- 9e: 0
- 10: 2
- 11: 4
- 0: 1 (I really dislike how some incorporate national flags into their design - that really lacks NPOV. The wiki's are based on language - not nationality)
Robert Lee 01:24, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 2 (too crowded)
- 1b: 1 (ant is not even official mascott yet and should never be, even more crowded)
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1 (these are all very ugly)
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 2 (this ant thing is ugly and the connection is vague)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1 (same as 7, only worse)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3 (brackets are ugly here, vague meaning)
- 11: 1
- 0: 1 (this has so many problems...)
- 1a:2
- 1b:4
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:3
- 3a:2
- 3b:2
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:4
- 5a:4
- 5b:1
- 5c:3
- 5d:1
- 5e:5
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:1
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:3
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:3
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:2
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 1
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10 : 3
- 11 : 1
- 0 : 4
- 5b:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:4
- 7d:3
- 7e:3
- 9a:4
- 9b:4
- 9c:4
- 9d:4
- 9e:5
- 10:3
- 11:5
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 4
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 4
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 3
- 8: 1
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 2
Minesweeper 08:22, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 1
- 0: 2
AndrewKepert 08:31, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 2 (still too busy for a logo)
- 1b: 1 (blott on the landscape)
- 2a: 2 (too generic)
- 2b: 4 (globe too busy)
- 2c: 5 (maybe tweak the colours, or go monochrome)
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 1 (what is it with the ant?)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4 (beautiful flower)
- 11: 3
- 0: 4
Kurt Jansson 09:15, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 5 (but without the flags - who had this stupid idea?)
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 3
- 0: 2
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 4
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 5
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 3
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 5
- 1a:3(expressive, but too cluttered)
- 1b:1(more clutter)
- 2a:2 (clear and simple, but not expressive)
- 2b:2 (")
- 2c:3 (simple and nice, but expression not clear)
- 2d:3 (")
- 2e:2 (clear and simple but not expressive)
- 3a:2 (clear and simple, but too direct expression)
- 3b:1 (pen out of context)
- 4a:1 (too direct reference to W)
- 4b:1 ( simple, but not expressive)
- 4c:1 (not expressive)
- 4d:2 (good graphic, but not expressive)
- 5a:1 (book immutable, therefore inappropriate)
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1(not sure of its meaning-I think book again, also too complex)
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1 (book again)
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:3 (good graphic, but expression not too clear)
- 9a:1 (book again)
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:3 (very expressive, but too simple,not sure of sunflower meaning)
- 11:1 (book again)
- 0:4 (wordy,but simple and familiar until something better comes along)
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 4
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 4
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 2
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 5
- 2b: 5
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 3
- 1a: 2 too coloured
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 1 .
- 2b: 1 |
- 2c: 1 } too simple, look like a corporation logo
- 2d: 1 |
- 2e: 1 '
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 1 .
- 5b: 1 |
- 5c: 1 } look like the M$ logos
- 5d: 1 |
- 5e: 1 '
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5 rhaa, lovely!
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4 lovely, too
- 11: 1 I hate doves (ka-boom!)
- 0: 2
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 3
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 2
- 11: 3
- 0: 2
{ MB | マイカル } 19:19, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 2
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 5
- 6c: 5
- 7a: 4
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 5
- 7d: 5
- 7e: 5
- 8: 4
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 1
- 11: 4
- 0: 1
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 5
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 5
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 4
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 5
- 7e: 2
- 8: 1
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 5
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 4
- 9e: 4
- 10: 3
- 11: 2
- 0: 1 (I reserved this score for the worst one of all)
- 1a: 1 (cluttered, not logo-ish)
- 1b: 1 (even worse)
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 5
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 5
- 5b: 1 (ugly gap)
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 2
- 0: 2
- 1a: 2 (very cluttered)
- 1b: 1 (I don't like the ant)
- 2a: 2 (OK, but a bit bland)
- 2b: 5 (Nice, looks good)
- 2c: 5 (I really like this one -- would have preferred the globe rather than the dot, though)
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4 (Would fit nicely in the corner of the screen)
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 3 (Doesn't signify much to me)
- 4d: 3 (ditto)
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 2 (Prefer green to blue)
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 2 (Sunflowers don't do much for me)
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1 (Argh! I really hate that ant)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3 (OK)
- 9a: 1 (Ants again...)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 3
- 0: 3 (Though I'm not keen about all the national flags...)
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
My only intention is to optimize my voting influence. Most of logos I voted 1 are not bad at all.
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 2
- 8: 3
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 4
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 2
- 10: 5
- 11: 3
- 0: 3
I just feel like making a first vote. Update.
- 1a: 4
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 4 (with centred wikipedia name)
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 3
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 5
- 11: 3
- 1a: 4 (while there is still too much things on it, a light version for 8x8 would be ok)
- 1b: 2 (I like Miwiki, I don't like on the earth)
- 2a: 4 (I can see a I O and A, doesn't mean anything, but nice one)
- 2b: 3 (The sphere is too complex compared to the rest)
- 2c: 4 (I don't like color set (WinXP?) but it's simple and nice)
- 2d: 4 (but please, not this font !!)
- 2e: 1 (even uglier than the first sphere)
- 3a: 5 (nice, light efficient, well, don't like the W, what about Vikipedio ?)
- 3b: 5 (nice, light efficient, well, the gray circle doesn't look nice)
- 4a: 2 (nice, good looking, but W... And Wikipedio ?)
- 4b: 2 (nice, but... It reminds me an already existing logo)
- 4c: 2 (nice, but... Yet another W... And Wikipedio ?)
- 4d: 2 (nice, but... Yet another W... And Wikipedio ?)
- 5a: 3 (nice, but too long)
- 5b: 3 (nice, but the border is missing)
- 5c: 3 (nice, but too long)
- 5d: 3 (nice, but the border is missing)
- 5e: 4 (well, can't put a 3 here, all the problems with others from the serie are solved)
- 6a: 2 (don't like the shape)
- 6b: 2 (don't like the shape)
- 6c: 2 (don't like the shape)
- 7a: 2 (too complex for a logo, but I still like Miwiki for a mascott)
- 7b: 2 (too complex for a logo, but I still like Miwiki for a mascott)
- 7c: 2 (too complex for a logo, but I still like Miwiki for a mascott)
- 7d: 2 (too complex for a logo, but I still like Miwiki for a mascott)
- 7e: 2 (too complex for a logo, but I still like Miwiki for a mascott)
- 8: 3 (too complex for a logo, but may be simplied perhaps?)
- 9a: 3 (Miwiki for a mascott, not for a logo)
- 9b: 3 (Miwiki for a mascott, not for a logo)
- 9c: 3 (Miwiki for a mascott, not for a logo)
- 9d: 3 (Miwiki for a mascott, not for a logo)
- 9e: 3 (Miwiki for a mascott, not for a logo)
- 10: 1 (Don't like photo in logos)
- 11: 2 (Don't like this blue...)
- 0: 3 (Difficult to vote for all at the same time, don't like fr, do really like one's like meta)
Crusadeonilliteracy 22:31, 17 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:5
- 1b:5
- 2a:2
- 2b:5
- 2c:5
- 2d:5
- 2e:5
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:3
- 4b:2
- 4c:1
- 4d:4
- 5a:3
- 5b:1
- 5c:4
- 5d:1
- 5e:3
- 6a:1
- 6b:2
- 6c:1
- 7a:3
- 7b:2
- 7c:4
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:3
- 9a:2
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:2
- 11:4
- 0:3
Vancouverguy 01:49, 18 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1 (spider makes it too busy)
- 2a: 5
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 2 (red is too dark)
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 5
- 4b: 5
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 5
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 3
Lorenzarius 02:53, 18 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 4
- 11: 2
- 0: 2
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 4
- 11: 2
- 0: 2
- 1a 1 (visual eyesore)
- 1b 1 (too busy and bloated)
- 2a 5 (perfect and simple)
- 2b 3
- 2c 3
- 2d 3
- 2e 3
- 3a 2
- 3b 2
- 4a 5 (funny and witty simple)
- 4b 2 (looks too much like an the Olympic logo of 2002)
- 4c 2
- 4d 2
- 5a 2 (too corporate!)
- 5b 2
- 5c 2
- 5d 2
- 5e 2
- 6a 1 (has taboo sunflower)
- 6b 1
- 6c 1
- 7a 3 (the purpose of the ant is...)
- 7b 3
- 7c 3
- 7d 3
- 7e 3
- 8 2 (too complex and busy)
- 9a 1 (CORNY AS HELL)
- 9b 1
- 9c 1
- 9d 1
- 9e 1
- 10 1 (has taboo sunflower)
- 11 5
- 0 1
- 1a: 3 (crowded, does not scale well to icon format)
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1 (inconsistent style)
- 2c: 3 (looks to me like reader is enclosed in 'round office cubicle')
- 2d: 5 nice subtle colors, great as icon as well, different connotations possible
- 2e: 1 (inconsistent style)
- 3a: 3 (nice graphic, but the background squares do not convey any meaning)
- 3b: 3 (see 3a)
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 3 (nice graphic, but who will see a 'W' without being told ?)
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1 (too much detail, will be messy when scaled down and what does it have to do with Wikipedia?)
- 6b: 1 see 6a
- 6c: 1 see 6a
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1 (too crowded)
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 4 (nice grapic, but does not scale to icon size well)
- 10: 1 (very bad graphic)
- 11: 1 (bad graphic, but first of all, peace dove is such a cliché, overused, worn out)
- 0: 1
- 1a: 4 (but too cluttered / crowded)
- 1b: 1 (I don't like the ant picture, altough i like ants, meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 2a: 2 (meaning of i unclear)
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 3 (like the embracing)
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 3 (do not like the colors)
- 3b: 3 (do not like the colors)
- 4a: 2 (altough nice idea)
- 4b: 1 (I don't like those sharp pointy things)
- 4c: 2 (W is hard to see)
- 4d: 4 (nice and dynamic)
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2 (too empty)
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 2 (too empty)
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 4 (but not that thin font)
- 6b: 3 (please: not that thin font)
- 6c: 2 (please: not that thin font)
- 7a: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough i like ants + meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 7b: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough ... meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 7c: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough ... meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 7d: 1 (the best ant)
- 7e: 1 (the worst ant)
- 8: 1 (very nice, but no logo)
- 9a: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough i like ants + meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 9b: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough i like ants + meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 9c: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough i like ants + meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 9d: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough i like ants + meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 9e: 1 (don't like ant picture, altough i like ants + meaning of the ant symbol is great)
- 10: 4 please: brackets barely visible/transparant/pale: a visitor does not know what the brackets mean. Wikipedia shold be for the readers, not for editors!
- 11: 3 (very nice, better with hint to internet)
- 0: 3
- 1a:3
- 1b:1
- 2a:2
- 2b:1
- 2c:3
- 2d:2
- 2e:1
- 3a:5
- 3b:3
- 4a:2
- 4b:3
- 4c:3
- 4d:3
- 5a:5
- 5b:2
- 5c:4
- 5d:2
- 5e:3
- 6a:2
- 6b:3
- 6c:3
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:2
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:4
- 11:2
- 0:3
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 5
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 2
- 0: 2
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 5
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 3
- 1a: 3 (can live with that)
- 1b: 1 (Heeellooo: logo NOT mascot!)
- 2a: 1 (info-point, now at every major attraction...)
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 3 (nice and simple. Too simple?)
- 2d: 1 (sees anyone besides me the Martini with the cherry?)
- 2e: 1 (A globe in a Martini...)
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 3 (well I prefer the ring in white)
- 4a: 1 (a logo may be inspired by a letter, but has to be more than that)
- 4b: 1 (winter already?)
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 3 (like I said at 4a)
- 5a: 5 (this is nice and not too simple)
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5 (nice, compact and not simple, still: I prefer green - I'm sure the word can be exchanged with other languages)
- 6a: 1 (agree with Nommonomanac: Garden Center)
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1 ( I have no "ant"icipation but as said: LOGO, not MASCOTT)
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5 (witty and well designed)
- 9a: 1 (get the vermin out of here)
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5 (I simply like the lean design)
- 11: 1 (peace, man!)
- 0: 1
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 1
- 0: 3
- 1a:1 (too complex)
- 1b:1
- 2a:1 (no color)
- 2b:1
- 2c:4
- 2d:4
- 2e:2 (too complex)
- 3a:5
- 3b:5
- 4a:3
- 4b:3
- 4c:3
- 4d:4
- 5a:1 (Too much like MicroSoft)
- 5b:4
- 5c:1
- 5d:4
- 5e:2
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:3
- 7a:1 (too much detail)
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1 (too much)
- 9a:1 (Name is distorted)
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:3
- 11:2
- 0:1 (Too many distinct varieties)
- 1a:2
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:2
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:2
- 4d:4
- 5a:5
- 5b:3
- 5c:4
- 5d:3
- 5e:3
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:2
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:5
- 0:1
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 3
- 8: 2
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 4
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 4
- 11: 4
- 0: 4
- 1a: 1 (like the concept, but too cluttered)
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 4 (good, but not quite there yet)
- 2c: 2 (the colours ruin it, I think)
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 5 (both are excellent)
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 3 (I'm just not a fan of the sunflower concept)
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1 (Miwiki is very cute, but he doesn't work well in a logo)
- 10: 1 (nice photo, but I don't want brackets in the logo)
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 3
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 2 (the ant doesn't blend well with the puzzleworld)
- 2a: 2 (too plain)
- 2b: 2 (a bit better but...)
- 2c: 4 (great - I'd just make the Japanese version read "ウィキペディア")
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2 (it's not easy to recognize it as a lamp)
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 3 (yes... I like blue better than green)
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1 (I feel dizzy when I look at the picture... plus - I can hardly read the text!)
- 6b: 1 (same reasons)
- 6c: 1 (same reasons)
- 7a: 3 (I like the color of the ant)
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 4 (I like the way the ant seems to collaborate with the project. Plus, I really like the color of the ant - smurf blue)
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 2 (it doesn't really tell me anything)
- 11: 2 (I like the design, but hate the color. It would be much better off with a darker blue)
- 0: 2
CabalamatReally 23:17, 18 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 3 (OK, bit complex)
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1 (not colourful enuf)
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 5 (very nice)
- 3b: 4 (don't like grey circle)
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 3
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 2
- 0: 1
Basil Fawlty 23:52, 18 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:5
- 1b:1 (the ant looks a bit ridiculous)
- 2a:3
- 2b:4
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:2
- 3a:3
- 3b:4 (the pen is really much more descriptive of Wikipedia's function than the lamp)
- 4a:1(a, b and c are too simple for my liking)
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:2
- 5a:5 (the color doesn't matter to me as much, but I would really like to see #5 in the corner of my screen)
- 5b:5
- 5c:5
- 5d:5
- 5e:5
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:1 (I could do without the ant)
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:4
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:3
- 0:1 (I do think we need a logo change)
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 2
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 5
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5 with b, an excellent print pair. Few colors, easy to recognise.
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1 wish I could give ants less than 1.
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 4
- 0: 5
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 5
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 5
- 7d: 5
- 7e: 5
- 7f: 5
- 8 : 3
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 3
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 3
- 10: 4
- 11: 1
- 0 : 4
- 1a:5
- 1b:4
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:2
- 3b:2
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:3
- 7a:4
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:2
- 8:4
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:4
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:4
- 3b:2
- 4a:2
- 4b:4
- 4c:5
- 4d:4
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:5
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:4
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:5
- 1b:3
- 2a:1
- 2b:2
- 2c:2
- 2d:1
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:3
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:4
- 5a:3
- 5b:4
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:3
- 6a:5
- 6b:3
- 6c:4
- 7a:5
- 7b:5
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e: 4
- 8:5
- 9a:4
- 9b:5
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:4
- 10:5
- 11:4
- 0:2
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 3
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 5
- 6c: 4
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 3
- 11: 4
- 0: 3
- 1a: 5 (I don’t know what it looks like when shrunk or in black & white.)
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 3
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4.5 (Nice sharp colors, but a little ordinary.)
- 2d: 4.5
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 4.5
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 4
- 6b: 4
- 6c: 5
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 3.5
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4
- 11: 5
- 0: 4 (I like the idea of having each country retain a unique logo. It also reminds users of the different biases that may occur.)
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 5
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 5
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 4
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 4
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 1
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 1
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
Stephane Simard 01:16, 20 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 5 (very representative: unfinished puzzle, sphere=globality, languages)
- 1b: 4 (the ant looks like it's eating the sphere)
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 1 (7c through 9b: very poor designs, but workable)
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 10: 4 (pleasant design: flower=freedom + wiki brackets)
- 0: 3 (lower scores: better keep old design)
(the rest of the logos, though they may look good, are, in my opinion, completely inappropriate for Wikipedia)
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:4
- 3a:4
- 3b:3
- 4a:4
- 4b:3
- 4c:5 (my favorite)
- 4d:4
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:3
- 5d:3
- 5e:3
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:4
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:5 (my second favorite)
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:3
- 11:2
- 0:3
- 1a:5
- 2c:4
- 3a:5
- 5e:4
- 10:4
- 11:2
- 0:2
I reserve a right to change my vote if i feel it's going to make more strategically stronger. This vote doesn't express my opinion.
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:5
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:5
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:1 (good concept, but needs much refinement, more smoothing, less clutter)
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 5
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 5 (I think this design is best variant of 6, though I prefer the blues of 6a)
- 6c: 1
- 8: 5
- 10:5
- 11:4
- 0: 4
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 4
- 4a: 3
- 0: 2
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 3
- 7a: 4
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 3
- 8: 4 (I like it, but it's a very complex image: very lowres will be hard)
- 9a: 4
- 9b: 3 (too unnatural blue)
- 9c: 4
- 9d: 3 (too unnatural blue)
- 9e: 3 (too unnatural blue)
- 0: 2
- 1a:1
- 1b:2
- 2a:1
- 2b:2
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:4
- 4a:4
- 4b:3
- 4c:3
- 4d:3
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:3
- 7a:2
- 7b:2
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e: 3
- 8:3
- 9a:4
- 9b:4
- 9c:5
- 9d:4
- 9e:4
- 10:3
- 11:1
- 0:0
- 1a:5 (I like it!)
- 1b:1 (Wikipedia invaded by parasites!)
- 2a:1 (looks European)
- 2b:1 (looks European)
- 2c:1 (looks European)
- 2d:1 (looks European)
- 2e:1 (looks European)
- 3a:3
- 3b:1 (Who still uses fountain pens?)
- 4a:2
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:1 (Microsoft)
- 5b:1 (Microsoft)
- 5c:1 (Microsoft)
- 5d:1 (Microsoft)
- 5e:1 (Microsoft)
- 6a:1 (there are no sunflowers on the 'pedia)
- 6b:1 (there are no sunflowers on the 'pedia)
- 6c:1 (there are no sunflowers on the 'pedia)
- 7a:1 (call the exterminators)
- 7b:1 (call the exterminators)
- 7c:1 (call the exterminators)
- 7d:1 (call the exterminators)
- 7e:1 (call the exterminators)
- 8:2
- 9a:1 (call the exterminators)
- 9b:1 (call the exterminators)
- 9c:1 (call the exterminators)
- 9d:1 (call the exterminators)
- 9e:1 (call the exterminators)
- 10:1 (there are no sunflowers on the 'pedia)
- 11:1 (too plain)
- 0:3
Kris Kaiser 23:36, 20 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:5
- 5b:1
- 5c:5
- 5d:1
- 5e:4
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:5
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:5
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:2
- 2c:3
- 2d:2
- 2e:2
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:2
- 4b:3
- 4c:4
- 4d:2
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:5
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:3
- 11:1
- 0:3
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:5
- 2b:5
- 2c:5
- 2d:5
- 2e:5
- 3a:4
- 3b:5
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:4
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:2
- 1b:2
- 2a:4
- 2b:2
- 2c:3
- 2d:2
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:4
- 4b:2
- 4c:3
- 4d:5
- 5a:3
- 5b:3
- 5c:4
- 5d:3
- 5e:4
- 6a:3
- 6b:3
- 6c:3
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:5
- 0:0
- 1a:4
- 1b:4
- 2a:4 Not too bad
- 2b:5 (Very imaginative)
- 2c:4 same as 2a
- 2d:5 (I like it)
- 2e:5 (Very representative of what wikipedia shoud be)
- 3a:2
- 3b:2
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:1
- 8: 2
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 0:1
Jeffdelonge 15:06, 21 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:3
- 1b:3
- 2a:3
- 2b:5
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:2
- 4a:2
- 4b:4
- 4c:2
- 4d:4
- 5a:2
- 5b:4
- 5c:2
- 5d:3
- 5e:4
- 6a:3
- 6b:3
- 6c:3
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e:3
- 8:3
- 9a:5
- 9b:3
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:5
- 11:2
- 0:3
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 5
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 5
- 11: 1
- 0: 5
- 1a: 4
- 1b: 3
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 1
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 2
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 4
- 7d: 4
- 7e: 4
- 8: 3
- 9a: 3
- 9b: 4
- 9c: 5
- 9d: 5
- 9e: 5
- 10: 2
- 11: 4 (too large...)
- 0: 1
Giskart Walter 20:58, 21 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit
- 1a:4
- 1b:3
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:2
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:2
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:2
- 0:5
- 1a:3
- 1b:2
- 2a:3
- 2b:4
- 2c:4
- 2d:4
- 2e:2
- 3a:2
- 3b:2
- 4a:4
- 4b:2
- 4c:5
- 4d:5
- 5a:5
- 5b:2
- 5c:5
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:4
- 6b:5
- 6c:3
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:4
- 7d:5
- 7e:3
- 8: 5
- 9a:4
- 9b:5
- 9c:4
- 9d:4
- 9e:4
- 10:3
- 11:5
- 0:3
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8: 1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:1
- 0:5
- 1a:2
- 1b:2
- 2a:4
- 2b:3
- 2c:4
- 2d:4
- 2e:3
- 3a:4
- 3b:4
- 4a:5
- 4b:5
- 4c:5
- 4d:5
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:2
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e: 2
- 8:1
- 9a:2
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:1
- 11:4
- 0:3
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:3
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:4
- 4d:5
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:4
- 5e:5
- 6a:5
- 6b:5
- 6c:4
- 7a:4
- 7b:3
- 7c:3
- 7d:4
- 7e:3
- 8:1
- 9a:4
- 9b:4
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:5
- 11:1
- 0:3
- 1a:1
- 1b:2
- 2a:2
- 2b:2
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:2
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:3
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:3
- 5b:2
- 5c:4
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:3
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:2
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:5
- 8:1
- 9a:2
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:4
- 10:5
- 11:1
- 0:3
Jose Ramos 22:08, 22 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:5
- 1b:4
- 2a:2
- 2b:3
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:3
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:4
- 6b:3
- 6c:2
- 7a:2
- 7b:3
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:2
- 8:1
- 9a:3
- 9b:3
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:4
- 11:2
- 0:4
Dante Alighieri 23:00, 22 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a: 4
- 1b: 3 (the ant clutters things up a bit)
- 2a: 3 (I don't like the "i", the globe is better)
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 4
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 3 (It's OK, but I like the stylized "lamp" better)
- 4a: 2 (I just don't like these. They don't seem to fit with my idea of the appropriate "look" for our logo. Purely a subjective response.)
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 2 (These ones are a bit boring for my taste)
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 2
- 6a: 1 (Nice enough images, but they look too much like the Britannica logo)
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 2 (I just don't get the whole ant thing... not my taste)
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 5 (I love it!)
- 9a: 2 (ants again, see above)
- 9b: 2
- 9c: 2
- 9d: 2
- 9e: 2
- 10: 2 (the sunflower just doesn't look right)
- 11: 2 (the dove is too closely tied with Christianity for my tastes)
- 0: 5 (you know, I really kinda like the existing logo)
- 1a: 5
- 1b: 2
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 4
- 11: 4
- 0: 4
Yanyang1985 00:39, 23 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:4
- 1b:3
- 2a:3
- 2b:3
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:5
- 3b:4
- 4a:4
- 4b:4
- 4c:4
- 4d:5
- 5a:3
- 5b:3
- 5c:4
- 5d:4
- 5e:4
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e:3
- 8:3
- 9a:3
- 9b:3
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:4
- 11:2
- 0:4
- 1a: 2
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 4
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 2
- 3a: 5
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 3
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 3
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 1
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 4
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 3
- 11: 2
- 0: 3
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 5
- 2d: 5
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 3
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 4
- 4c: 5
- 4d: 5
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 5
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 5
- 6a: 4
- 6b: 4
- 6c: 3
- 7a: 2
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 2
- 7d: 2
- 7e: 2
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 3
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 3
- 0: 1
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:2
- 2b:2
- 2c:3
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:2
- 3b:5
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:5
- 7b:5
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e: 3
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:5
- 0:3
- 1a:2 (too complicated)
- 1b:2 (too complicated)
- 2a:4
- 2b:4
- 2c:5
- 2d:4
- 2e:4
- 3a:3
- 3b:4
- 4a:3
- 4b:4
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:3
- 5b:3
- 5c:3
- 5d:3
- 5e:3
- 6a:1 (no connection to an encyclopedia)
- 6b:1 (no connection to an encyclopedia)
- 6c:1 (no connection to an encyclopedia)
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e:3
- 8:4 (good idea, complicated)
- 9a:3
- 9b:3
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:1 (no connection to an encyclopedia)
- 11:2
- 0:4
- 1a:3
- 1b:4
- 2a:1
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:2
- 4a:2
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:2
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:2
- 7b:2
- 7c:3
- 7d:5
- 7e: 4
- 8:1
- 9a:3
- 9b:4
- 9c:3
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:4
- 11:1
- 0:3
- 1a:5 nothwistanding claims of it being too cluttered.
- 1b:1 ant is out of context
- 2a:1 lack of colour
- 2b:1 id
- 2c:4
- 2d:4
- 2e:3 better a head than Earth. Earth also detracts from simplicity.
- 3a:2 too graphical, no obvious meaning
- 3b:3 id (less lacking on meaning)
- 4a:1 weak on originality.
- 4b:1
- 4c:1 too cute, anonymous corporation style
- 4d:1 id
- 5a:2
- 5b:1 1 for the hole
- 5c:2
- 5d:1 1 for the hole
- 5e:2
- 6a:2 maybe not so well suited to Wikipedia after all
- 6b:2 id
- 6c:2 id even though I like warm colours
- 7a:2
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:3
- 7e:3
- 8:3
- 9a:2 graphically i'm not convinced.,
- 9b:2 and they rely too much on letters
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:4 refreshing!
- 11:3 why not ?
- 0:3 (but really from 1(Nupedia) to maybe 4 (en:Wikipedia))
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:2
- 2b:4
- 2c:3
- 2d:4
- 2e:3
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:2
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:3
- 5b:2
- 5c:4
- 5d:2
- 5e:3
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:2
- 9a:2
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:3
- 11:2
- 0:1
- 1a:0 (ugly, busy, won't work at smaller sizes, hard to coordinate colors, etc)
- 1b:0 (nice idea, but makes a terrible logo)
- 2a:2
- 2b:2
- 2c:5 (the best)
- 2d:4
- 2e:4
- 3a:4
- 3b:4
- 4a:4
- 4b:4
- 4c:4
- 4d:4
- 5a:3
- 5b:3
- 5c:3
- 5d:3
- 5e:3
- 6a:3
- 6b:3
- 6c:3
- 7a:3
- 7b:2
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e: 1
- 8:4
- 9a:3
- 9b:3
- 9c:3
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:3
- 11:3
- 0:0 (words just don't belong in a logo)
- 1a:3 — Great concept, but too dense; won't reduce well.
- 1b:1 — Incongruous insect incursion!
- 2a:2 — Simple & clean, but too generic.
- 2b:3
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:5 — A Masterpiece! :)
- 3b:4 — This one has potential.
- 4a:2
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:2
- 5a:4
- 5b:3
- 5c:4 — I like the blue better.
- 5d:2 — Gap on right side needs filling.
- 5e:3 — Better than 5d.
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:1 — Hmm... *Splat*
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:4
- 9a:1 — Can anybody recommend a good exterminator?
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:2 — Flower Power is sooo 1960s! :)
- 11:1 — Save this one for Wikibible.
- 0:1 — Yawn.
- 1a:2 (to busy with the text in the puzzle, to dark)
- 1b:1 (even more busy)
- 2a:2 (to simple - boring)
- 2b:4 (maybe to busy)
- 2c:5 (great! I really like this!)
- 2d:4 (missing the white W ;-)
- 2e:2 (to busy)
- 3a:3 (I like this, but how does it look in black&white?, what about Vikipedio?)
- 3b:4 (still maybe a problem with black&white version)
- 4a:2 (boring)
- 4b:2 (a snowflake, hmm maybe a good idea, but it doesnt stand out, I would forget it fast)
- 4c:4 (Simple but interesting. I like this, but there is still a problem with the W in Vikipedia - but it works fine in black&white)
- 4d:2 (too busy)
- 5a:1 (to large)
- 5b:2 (better but graphically not ok)
- 5c:1 (lo large)
- 5d:2
- 5e:3 (more compact, looks better, but text in logo is not a good idea)
- 6a:1 (graphic is not ok)
- 6b:1 (graphic not ok, and it is too busy)
- 6c:1 (graphic not ok, and it is too busy)
- 7a:1 (to busy for a logo and to many colors)
- 7b:1 (-)
- 7c:1 (-)
- 7d:1 (-)
- 7e:1 (-)
- 8:1 (nice but to busy for a logo and to many colors)
- 9a:1 (to qute and cartoonish, to many colors for it to work in black&white, what about Vikipedio?)
- 9b:1 (-)
- 9c:1 (-)
- 9d:1 (-)
- 9e:1 (-)
- 10:2 (like the flower, but not ok i black&white)
- 11:2 (too peacefull, what about a black&white version? The logo would change dramatically if the word looks different as in another language)
- 0:1 (to boring, text in english in the sphere)
- 1a: 5 (I don't like the colored puzzle pieces, but a good logo)
- 1b: 2 (the ant doesn't help)
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 3
- 2c: 1 (too much random color)
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 3
- 4a: 1
- 5a: 1
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6b: 1
- 7e: 1
- 10: 2
- 0: 2
- 1a:5
- 1b:3
- 2a:
- 2b:
- 2c:
- 2d:
- 2e:
- 3a:
- 3b:
- 4a:
- 4b:
- 4c:
- 4d:
- 5a:
- 5b:
- 5c:
- 5d:
- 5e:
- 6a:
- 6b:
- 6c:
- 7a:
- 7b:
- 7c:
- 7d:
- 7e:
- 8:
- 9a:
- 9b:
- 9c:
- 9d:
- 9e:
- 10:
- 11:
- 0:5
---
- 1a: 3
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 2
- 2c: 2
- 2d: 2
- 2e: 3
- 3a: 1
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 2
- 4b: 1
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 3
- 5c: 3
- 5d: 3
- 5e: 3
- 6a: 2
- 6b: 3
- 6c: 2
- 7a: 3
- 7b: 4
- 7c: 3
- 7d: 5
- 7e: 4
- 8: 4
- 9a: 2
- 9b: 4
- 9c: 4
- 9e: 4
- 10: 2
- 11: 3
- 0: 3
- 1a:4 (while i'm tempted to mark this down because it is winning, and because it was my main competition from day one, I won't. It's a good concept, but is limited by how easily is can be scaled down, or re-purposed. The single puzzle piece favicons show a way around the scaling problem, but trying to put this into embroidery for a cap or t-shirt would be difficult. It also depends a lot on several elements to work.)
- 1b:3 (while I like Miwiki, I'm against it on this logo)
- 2a:2 (considered withdrawing this one, but was convinced to keep it at the last moment)
- 2b:4.75
- 2c:5 (well, obviously one of mine had to get it!)
- 2d:4.75
- 2e:4.75
- 3a:4 (like the symbolism, and think it looks more complete with the lamp symbol extending to the break between the squares)
- 3b:3.75 (without the grey, it would be good, but it also shows a fountain pen nib. Elegant, but not all that contemporary)
- 4a:4 (good concept, but "w" which kinda makes it limiting)
- 4b:3 (networked? hmm, not sure if that comes across over the instant snowflake/winter image)
- 4c:4 ("w" again, but good concept)
- 4d:4.5 (nice 2.5d touch, pleasant and warm colours, best of candidate 4)
- 5a:4 (workable, but dependant on the text, without which would look out of place)
- 5b:3 (need the text within the "book)
- 5c:4 (blue works well too)
- 5d:3 (see 5b)
- 5e:2.5 (begins to lose integrity here. too busy in the middle)
- 6a:2.5 (not sure what sunflowers represent, but the execution here is okay, not appropriate though)
- 6b:2.5 (see 6a)
- 6c:2.5 (see 6a)
- 7a:3 (neutral for all these entries, it can work if Miwiki is chosen as mascot, but not if it isn't)
- 7b:3
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e:3
- 8:4 (I like the golden ratio, but something is missing, just not sure what)
- 9a:3.25 (prefer the straight rectangle as opposed to the book outline)
- 9b:3.75 (like this as a stand alone, even better if Miwiki is chosen as mascot)
- 9c:3.25 (doesn't work as well, see 9a)
- 9d:3.75 (see 9b)
- 9e:3.75 (see 9b)
- 10:3 (neutral, because I don't know what the sunflower is all about, and the square brackets I don't think are needed in a logo)
- 11:1 (no! (sorry, Abi))
- 0:3.5 (this and 1a share the globalised text concept, and I like it, although I think the original is becoming a little dated)
- 1a:5
- 1b:4
- 2a:1
- 2b:2
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:1
- 3a:1
- 3b:2
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:3
- 6b:3
- 6c:3
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:3
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:3
- 11:2
- 0:4
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 1
- 2b: 1
- 2c: 1
- 2d: 1
- 2e: 1
- 3a: 2
- 3b: 2
- 4a: 4
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 4
- 5b: 4
- 5c: 4
- 5d: 4
- 5e: 4
- 6a: 5
- 6b: 5
- 6c: 5
- 7a: 5
- 7b: 5
- 7c: 5
- 7d: 5
- 7e: 5
- 8: 1
- 9a: 5
- 9b: 5
- 9c: 5
- 9d: 5
- 9e: 5
- 10: 3
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
- 1a:5
- 1b:0
- 2a:4
- 2b:3
- 2c:4
- 2d:3
- 2e:2
- 3a:4
- 3b:4
- 4a:3
- 4b:3
- 4c:3
- 4d:4
- 5a:3
- 5b:4
- 5c:3
- 5d:4
- 5e:5
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:4
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:2
- 0:3
- 1a:5
- 1b:2
- 2a:3
- 2b:3
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:2
- 3b:2
- 4a:2
- 4b:3
- 4c:2
- 4d:2
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:2
- 7a:2
- 7b:3
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:2
- 8:3
- 9a:2
- 9b:2
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:4
- 11:2
- 0:5
Greatpatton 08:34, 25 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:1
- 1b:2
- 2a:3
- 2b:3
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:3
- 3a:2
- 3b:2
- 4a:1
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:4
- 7b:4
- 7c:4
- 7d:4
- 7e: 4
- 8:1
- 9a:5
- 9b:5
- 9c:5
- 9d:5
- 9e:5
- 10:5
- 11:5
- 0:
- 1a:4
- 1b:2
- 2a:2
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:1
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:4
- 4b:3
- 4c:4
- 4d:4
- 5a:2
- 5b:3
- 5c:2
- 5d:3
- 5e:4
- 6a:2
- 6b:2
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:3
- 7c:1
- 7d:3 (I'd rather see the brackets in a different colour)
- 7e:2
- 8:3
- 9a:3
- 9b:3
- 9c:4
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:3
- 11:2
- 0:3
- 1a:3
- 1b:4
- 2a:2
- 2b:2
- 2c:5
- 2d:2
- 2e:4
- 3a:0
- 3b:0
- 4a:0
- 4b:0
- 4c:0
- 4d:2
- 5a:3
- 5b:3
- 5c:3
- 5d:3
- 5e:3
- 6a:4
- 6b:4
- 6c:5
- 7a:5
- 7b:4
- 7c:4
- 7d:4
- 7e:4
- 8:5
- 9a:4
- 9b:4
- 9c:4
- 9d:4
- 9e:5
- 10:2
- 11:2
- 0:3
- 1a:4
- 1b:2
- 2a:2
- 2b:3
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:2
- 3a:1
- 3b:1
- 4a:2
- 4b:2
- 4c:2
- 4d:4
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:3
- 5d:4
- 5e:2
- 6a:3
- 6b:4
- 6c:2
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:5
- 11:1
- 0:3
- 1a:4
- 1b:3
- 2a:4
- 2b:3
- 2c:3
- 2d:3
- 2e:4
- 3a:3
- 3b:3
- 4a:2
- 4b:4
- 4c:4
- 4d:3
- 5a:2
- 5b:2
- 5c:2
- 5d:2
- 5e:2
- 6a:3
- 6b:4
- 6c:4
- 7a:2
- 7b:2
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:2
- 8:4
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:5
- 11:3
- 0:2
- 1a:2
- 1b:1
- 2a:2
- 2b:3
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:2
- 3a:3
- 3b:2
- 4a:2
- 4b:2
- 4c:5
- 4d:5
- 5a:4
- 5b:2
- 5c:3
- 5d:2
- 5e:3
- 6a:1
- 6b:2
- 6c:1
- 7a:1
- 7b:1
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:1
- 11:1
- 0:1
- 1a:1
- 1b:1
- 2a:3
- 2b:5
- 2c:3
- 2d:2
- 2e:2
- 3a:2
- 3b:4
- 4a:3
- 4b:3
- 4c:1
- 4d:1
- 5a:1
- 5b:1
- 5c:1
- 5d:1
- 5e:1
- 6a:5
- 6b:5
- 6c:5
- 7a:2
- 7b:3
- 7c:2
- 7d:2
- 7e:3
- 8:1
- 9a:3
- 9b:4
- 9c:2
- 9d:3
- 9e:3
- 10:1
- 11:5
- 0:5
- 1a:5 (suggestion posted in the discussion page)
- 1b:5
- 2a:2
- 2b:3
- 2c:2
- 2d:2
- 2e:3
- 3a:2
- 3b:4
- 4a:2
- 4b:2
- 4c:3
- 4d:3
- 5a:3
- 5b:2
- 5c:3
- 5d:2
- 5e:3
- 6a:1
- 6b:1
- 6c:1
- 7a:4
- 7b:3
- 7c:3
- 7d:3
- 7e:3 (brackets in the logo will be the downfall of Wikipedia)
- 8:5 (suggestion posted in the discussion page)
- 9a:3
- 9b:3
- 9c:2
- 9d:2
- 9e:2
- 10:2
- 11:2
- 0:4
- 1a: 5 (No big surprise here)
- 1b: 5
- 2a: 2 ("i" isn't really international)
- 2b: 4 (horay for spheres!)
- 2c: 3
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 4
- 3a: 1 (races in a logo?)
- 3b: 1
- 4a: 2 (can't see the meaning)
- 4b: 3 (the cube is sorta neat)
- 4c: 2
- 4d: 2
- 5a: 1 (I don't want to think about Microsoft any more than I already have to)
- 5b: 1
- 5c: 1
- 5d: 1
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 3
- 6b: 1
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1 (it looks like the text on the book stopped for Miwiki)
- 7b: 1 (ditto, also I don't like double
- 7c: 3 (good composition, even though the stopped text still looks funny)
- 7d: 3
- 7e: 3
- 8: 4
- 9a: 3 (folded-over-page looks funny)
- 9b: 4
- 9c: 3
- 9d: 4
- 9e: 2 (the pushed letter doesn't come out well)
- 10: 2 (Wikipedia doesn't have much to do with sunflowers)
- 11: 2 (the dove may sort of establish a tone. Peace and love are pretty cool, but they're also POV)
- 0: 1 (not international and NPOV. Otherwise, it's a good logo, but those two concerns make it unacceptable)
- 1a: 1
- 1b: 1
- 2a: 2
- 2b: 4
- 2c: 4
- 2d: 3
- 2e: 5 (the best!!!!) - Globe should be a solid color when it will be scaled to a favicon.
- 3a: 4
- 3b: 4
- 4a: 1
- 4b: 2
- 4c: 3
- 4d: 4
- 5a: 3
- 5b: 2
- 5c: 2
- 5d: 2
- 5e: 1
- 6a: 1
- 6b: 2
- 6c: 1
- 7a: 1
- 7b: 2
- 7c: 1
- 7d: 1
- 7e: 1
- 8: 3
- 9a: 1
- 9b: 1
- 9c: 1
- 9d: 1
- 9e: 1
- 10: 2
- 11: 1
- 0: 1
Eclecticology 03:10, 21 Sep 2003 (UTC)
edit- 1a:2
- 1b:2
- 2a:1 (World University Games)
- 2b:1
- 2c:1
- 2d:1
- 2e:2
- 3a:1 (Westinghouse light bulb?)
- 3b:1
- 4a:2
- 4b:1
- 4c:1
- 4d:1 - meaningless blur
- 5a:3
- 5b:1
- 5c:3
- 5d:1
- 5e:2
- 6a:1
- 6b:2
- 6c:3
- 7a:3
- 7b:3
- 7c:1
- 7d:1
- 7e:1
- 8:1
- 9a:1
- 9b:1
- 9c:1
- 9d:1
- 9e:1
- 10:5
- 11:4
- 0:5
Template for voting
editCopy this template into the edit box to vote. Do not copy the wikitext source of the template -- that's not what you want to do. And please vote above this template.
==[[User:Myname]]== *1a: *1b: *2a: *2b: *2c: *2d: *2e: *3a: *3b: *4a: *4b: *4c: *4d: *5a: *5b: *5c: *5d: *5e: *6a: *6b: *6c: *7a: *7b: *7c: *7d: *7e: *8: *9a: *9b: *9c: *9d: *9e: *10: *11: *0: