Movement Charter/Community Consultations/2023/Banjar Wikimedian Community by Arcuscloud

General Information

Feedback channels: Live meeting and WhatsApp
Number of participants: 6

Feedback

Global Council

Open Questions regarding Fund Dissemination

What role should the Global Council have in fund dissemination?
Oversight or review of WMF decisions

Coordination with WMF

Other (please elaborate)

Should there be a committee that reports to the Global Council and handles central/cross-regional fund dissemination?

What should be the Global Council’s role with regards to the allocation of the funds within the WMF?
The Global Council should be consulted on the allocation of the funds within the WMF.

The Global Council should have no role in the allocation of the funds within the WMF and only be informed.

Other (please elaborate)

We believe that Global Council is suitable as oversighter or reviewer of WMF decisions.

Open Questions regarding Structure

Should the Global Council exist only as an executive body or should it exist as an executive body with an advisory board? (See scenarios below)
If the Global Council is an executive body with an advisory board, how are the members of both entities (executive body and advisory board) seated?

With its size, the Global Council must have adequate diversity and clout, but not be so large as to undermine effectiveness. As an executive body, how many members should the Global Council have?
Option 1: 9-13 members

Option 2: 17-21 members

Open Questions regarding Membership

With an intention to ensure fair representation, power balance, and promote diversity and inclusivity within the Global Council, we seek your inputs on the following:

Should there be some imposed limits to the membership in terms of movement representation?

It should be some imposed limits to the membership of Global Council. We want membership of Global Council represents certain regional or thematic so that it would be fair, not only for some regional or some thematic.
Please share your opinions about potential criteria of such limits:

Should there be a regional cap, e.g. max 3 persons from a single region? If yes, please specify the condition.

Should there be a home project or entity cap, e.g. max 2 persons from a single wiki project or affiliate? If yes, please specify the condition.

Should there be a specific cap for large^[1] language communities, projects, or affiliates, e.g. not more than 5 seats from between the 5 largest projects? If yes, please specify the condition.

Should there be any other limits for Global Council membership? If yes, please specify the condition.

Other feedback about the draft chapter:

To create Global Council, it is neccesary to create comittee team that focus on the whole process of forming Global Council.
...
...

Hubs

Community Question: Should there be a limit to how many hubs an affiliate can join? (Please elaborate on your answer.)

Yes, it should be a limit to how many hubs an affiliate can join. We also suggest that Global Council needs to design certain criteria for affiliates if they want to join hub, so that there are not many affiliates in one hub.

Other feedback about the draft chapter:

...
...
...

Roles & Responsibilities

...
...
...

Glossary

...
...
...

Miscellaneous feedback

...
...
...

↑ As determined by number of active editors for projects and voting members for affiliates

[1] As determined by number of active editors for projects and voting members for affiliates

[1]