Redirected user pages considered harmful
This page is kept for historical interest. Any policies mentioned may be obsolete. If you want to revive the topic, you can use the talk page or start a discussion on the community forum. |
Some people have set their user pages on some wiki, particularly here on Meta-Wiki, to redirect to their user pages on another wiki, such as their home language Wikipedia.
While on the surface this is a pretty neat thing, it's somewhat problematic, at least with the current (primitive) implementation of inter-wiki redirects:
- It obscures the links to the user contributions and user's talk page on the present wiki.
- If you change your mind, there's not a clean way to edit the redirect to put text back into it.
- You can go to a page that links to it, use "related changed" to bring up its history or a diff, and then click "edit" there.
- You can construct a URL to get at it in no-redirect mode: http://meta.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=User:My_name_here&redirect=no
- It surprises people by taking them to a different wiki.
Anyway, just thoughts. Improvements can be made to the system in future...
- We just need a "redirected from" option in the URL. Something like:
- I'll put it on my to do list. -- Tim Starling 16:08, 20 Sep 2003 (UTC)